It's no doubt that Maybelline's Great Lash Mascara is a favorite amongst all the beauty editors. For some odd reason, they just love it! Lindsay Price's character on Lipstick Jungle uses it!! For some odder reason, I never purchased a tube until recently just so I could see what the fuss is about.
To put it short, people either LOVE it or HATE it! There's no in betweens at all. Some of the complaints include:
- It does nothing to enhance the lashes
- It clumps
- It smudges and smears
Basically everything you don't want in a mascara.
But the people who love it say:
- It never clumps or smudges
- Their lashes has never been longer or more beautiful when using any other mascara
- It's their holy grail!!
Obviously, very very different opinions. For a while, I thought perhaps it was due to a lack of consistency between each tube, so some people got great ones, while others were on the bad receiving end. Another time I read that makeup artists loves it because it goes on very well on top of false lashes, almost like a glossy black coat. So I thought, perhaps if a person has naturally long lashes, then perhaps that's all they need!
But what about us normal gals with normal lashes? I have very light colored black lashes (well, they are black, but they aren't very dark.. argh.. you'll see in the pictures later), medium length, with a lot of curl. I don't use lash curlers and my lashes just curl. My left lashes curls a lot more than my right, but my right ones are more feathered and uniform. The left lashes do this weird tangly thing, so it looks ugly up close, but from a distance they look great. Odd, I know.
So like I previously mentioned, I bought 2 tubes (1 package, 2 for the price of 1 from Target!) a while ago, and I absolutely hated it! I applied it, and nothing. If anything, my lashes were just sticking together. The wand is so tiny, I feel like I'm not properly getting any mascara on it! When I applied more, I felt like my lashes just looked shorter, stumpier, and like they were glued together. I tried it a few more times, and results were the same. It also did smudge while it was super hard to get off!
Then came along an message from Diana at AdoreBeauty, asking if I could send her some Great Lash to Singapore. Apparently her and all her friends are crazy for it!! I shot back a surprised reply, asking if she was in fact crazy since it's such a shitty mascara. I told her I would do a review, take some pictures, and prove to her that it sucks!!
I grabbed my camera, applied concealer all over my eyes (so this way in the up close picture, my lids and bags don't look soo discolored and gross), and began snapping pictures of my naked lashes. I dug out that tube of Great Lash mascara from my box of "everyday" makeup, and began applying it. Wait, hold on, how come my lashes are looking so pretty? No way, this cannot be the same mascara I tried just a while back? It's the same tube! It's not dried out or anything! I applied more coats, and my lashes are just looking more pronounced and prettier. I won't say it lengthens, nor did it really add much volume, but it made my lashes pretty! It's like my own natural lashes, but better! Glossier! Darker!! And at the same time, natural!
Then I got it. I have an obsession with false lashes, and I love mascars that can give me that false lash look without actually wearing falsies. But when i'm doing a natural no makeup look, super voluminized lashes won't work as well. That's when you need a mascara like Great Lash, something that just transforms your lashes into a better, but still natural looking version of your lashes! It does like a little long to dry (more than a minute), so wait a while before you put a shirt on so it won't smudge everywhere. Take 10 minutes out to blow dry your hair then get dressed! It does smudge a bit over the course of the day since it's not waterproof, so if you have oily lids and watery eyes like me, you might just want to use it for a night out (where you aren't sweating tons!). Otherwise, it's really a pretty nice mascara. I think I'll give it 3.5 watermelons out of 5.
So what do you guys think about Maybelline's Great Lash Mascara? Do you strongly love it or hate it? Don't be shy and tell the truth!
*Sorry for the redness in my eyes. I have seasonal allergies, so my eyes are constantly red and watery. As you can see, it's not caused by the mascara. Also, click on the pictures to view a larger version.
No mascara on:



With Great Lash Mascara



With black eyeliner as well:


If you love it and want to buy it, click on the picture below for the link!
Latest Comments